Patches on the Pants
Reading a book on non-profit management and the great Peter Drucker comments on job descriptions. He writes: there comes a point when one has to look at what the job requires and design for that job, rather than saying this is how we have always done it. This is one of those critical decisions. It is one of the crucial tasks of the executive to know when to say “Enough is enough. Let’s stop improving. There are too many patches on those pants.” Taking a look at your organization - are there a lot of patchy pants?
The Muddled Middle
The great Franciscan author Richard Rohr writes and speaks regularly of the three phases of the life journey. Rohr often describes a human journey in three broad movements:
Early stage (order): You see the world in clear, simple terms—right vs. wrong, good vs. bad. You rely on rules, structure, and certainty.
The muddled middle (disorder): Your previous certainties stop working. Life gets complicated. You experience doubt, failure, paradox, or suffering.
Later stage (reorder): You come into a deeper, more compassionate, and integrated understanding of life.
I think there is relevance here to the work of the public administrator. The job is initially clear, simple, described, and structured. Certainly upon hire it is! And then as things progress and time goes by, you experience this period akin to the muddled middle. Complications ensue, you experience distress, there are items popping left and right that are “not on the job description,” there are gray lines and not just black and white, and so forth. Working through this — to get to Rohr’s “reorder” phase — takes time, personal growth and evolutionary practices, and focused, mindful development at the personal/professional/organizational level.
Being versus Doing
I know a lot of people that say they want to be something. In this specific case, it is a City Manager / County Administrator. “I want to be a City Manager!” they say. To which I reply, “are you prepared to do the work of the Manager?” There is a big difference between aspiring to be, and being, and then doing the work, on a day to day basis. The work is in the slop, the trenches, the bad days, the frustrations — one has to be ok with and reconcile those realities with the oft-pleasant aspirational aspects of simply holding the position itself.
Real-time Work
A coaching client of mine was recently due to experience a major weather event. This would be his first time managing such an event, and operating the Emergency Operations Center. It was a snow event, with lots of lead time and therefore, they could plan ahead and plan accordingly. I gave him one simple piece of advice - have a notebook (actual pen and paper) besides you all of the time. In real time, as things progress, use this notebook for one singular purpose – notetaking on processes, policies, people, programs, actions, and so forth that need to be addressed post-event. This could be the way some press communication was handled or how parking issues were resolved with the local municipality.
Surviving or Thriving
Organizations, and the leaders of them, often find themselves in one of three types of situations. Treading water, setting sail, or sinking. There’s also a straight duality assessment - which basically blends treading water and sinking into one in the same, leaving setting sail alone – are you surviving or are you thriving? Take stock in your organization first. Assess your performance and current status (be honest) against this simple metric. There’s not 7 out of 10 here really. Also, do the same with yourself as a person and as a leader. Self-reflect and take your time. Look at your schedule - are there events, activities and planned items that reflect your growth and growth opportunities and developments and progress? Or is it filled with stuff that is keeping things afloat. Static situations of “just getting by” aren’t bad. They’re fine. But if you stay there, you probably will just end up sinking.
Performance Appraisals
I was speaking with a coaching client recently and the subject of personal performance appraisals came up. They had a 7 member Board and their process was such that all 7 needed to file their appraisal/review by December 31st. Only three had complied. In the past, it was rarely that 7 provided. There was also a self-appraisal that the CEO needed to complete, themselves, annually by the same date as part of the process. I have seen many bad things happen when appraisal processes are not adhered to as specified in policy. The Board needs to comply and be reminded and maybe even harangued and cajoled in the run-up to the deadline, so they keep up with their end of the bargain. And the CEO should always comply. This is important and more than just CYA. It’s an essential part of the employment agreement and the CEO/Board compact. Leave nothing to chance or circumstances. Control your controllables.
Screenings
Most people know that at age 45 one is due for a colorectal screening. Other common ones include bone density scans at age 65 and the shingles vaccine at age 50. In your organization, what screenings should be taking place and at what years or milestone markers? Major budget officer or administrative officer turnover? A thorough financial audit (if not already done). Running a self-insured health program? Every five years, a dependent eligibility audit for your health insurance participants. Heavy in terms of policies, procedures and so forth? Every year (if you can) an analysis of policies and which ones should stay, go, and/or be amended. Have a Board? Upon changeover of a council or board, make sure you undergo a council-manager or administration-governance training. Institutionalizing these in your community or organization will be foundational to the long-term success and health of your organization.
Going Analog, Redux
I realize this is a bit like my pen and paper blog post of recent past, but there is something about the simplicity of not being around the technological aspects of our modern lives. Time in nature. A car ride without the satellite radio / podcast on bluetooth / hands-free call. A morning read with a “paper copy” of the morning newspaper, still cold from being in the box in the wee hours of a chilly winter day. I refer to these simplicities as “going analog.” I include such professional and organizational items like taking out pen and paper, walking to the office (if one can), holding meetings in person, phone calls versus Zooms, lunch meetings in person and so forth. There is nothing like these personal, “old school” touchpoints to take one back to the simpler times.
Pen and Paper
With technology in our face all the time, and the dings and pings of social media and phone notifications, how therapeutic it is to just sit down with pen and paper and think. Do a brain dump. Write out plans. Do resolutions. Review quarterly tracking. Develop a personal strategic plan. Write out a to-do list. Send people get well, touch-base, and/or thinking of you cards. Whatever it is, do it in pen and paper. You can thank me later.
Service
Service is a responsibility. We have obligations, not formal and contractual, but to me inherent, that indicate that we have a responsibility of serving others, of helping where and when we can, of paying it forward. You need not be a philanthropist or a community organizer. You could simply call on a neighbor in time of need. Hold open a door. Caretake for a loved one. Treat the opportunity of small, and big, service work as a solemn charge that you, as part of humanity, have.
Attentive Listening
Whether it be job interviews or simple conversations, more and more people I find are truly lacking in attentive and intentional listening. They’re distracted by other things. They are keen and intent (bad pun) on saying what they want to say and not simply listening to what the other person is saying. They are failing to acknowledge the other person’s point. This is beyond tact versus tactless. This is a big issue and generationally, alas, it does seem to be getting worse. Smartphones, text-based communication, distractions, and attention-demanding “everything” around us is surely to blame. Take a pause, listen, don’t jump to conclusions, don’t jump to what you wish to say irrespective of where the conversation is going, don’t talk over people, and show them your undivided — and undistracted — attention. While I would argue this is expected, common, regular and “of course” type counsel – doing so will separate you from what the “norm” seems to be these days.
Planning
I have written in these pages about planning and being planful. While maligned — think of the Progressive commercials, jokes about printed plane tickets, having a duplicate map for a big trip, and maybe a “worst-case scenario” prep bag — no has ever said I should have planned less. Usually, in hindsight, it’s the opposite. Preparation in sports, war, interviews, work, trips, teaching, consulting and even emergency management — is vitally important. Think about emergency management. Even in an area of life where you literally have NO idea what will happen (hence the word emergency) you plan for the types of emergencies you have have through continuity-of-operations-plans, hazard mitigation plans, etc.
Outside the Box’s Outside
I am writing a piece for Public Management. This article is focused on the space outside of the space that is outside the box. So-called “outside the box” thinking is a little tired, cliche and trite perhaps. But it still resonates for those in the world of public administration and organizational management. The point of my in-development article, which I will cross-publish in alternate non-paywall sources, is that the staleness of the phrase may signal that outside the box thinking isn’t that novel, unique or creative any longer. We need to go a step further. That’s my teaser and trailer. Article forthcoming.
Holidays
This is the joy of the holiday season. The lights in Main Street. The kids home from college. The gift-giving. The travel to and from. The family gatherings and the carrying out of seasonal traditions. No matter what religion you subscribe to, or maybe even none at all, you can revel and find appreciation for the splendors of this time of year.
Skiing
"There is knowledge about something, and then there is knowledge that comes from your experiences of that something. It's one thing to stand there in a lab coat with a clipboard recording data about lips. It's another thing to be kissed." attributed to Rob Bell. Lot of connections/relevance to this quote and public administration (and MPA program instruction) and coaching. I like to also think of one of my coaches, Alan Weiss and his quip on skiing. Paraphrasing - “would you want to take skiing lessons from someone who has never skied before?”
Being of Service
In the great holiday movie (perhaps it’s a cult classic for us 80s kids), The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, the main character, a woman organizing a pageant with some unruly kids, some misfits, etc - in response to a complaint/concern from a kid on the role they were playing states “there are no small parts, only small actors.” Again, I draw relevance to my work with public sector organizations. Every single employee, and every process and every plan and every project, has a small-to-grand (and everything in between) connection to the greater good, the whole, the purpose of this pursuit of public service. The part you play is critical. So is the part of your co-workers, your bosses, and your partners.
Contemplation and Action
Recently reading about some religions (in this case it was a mix of Protestantism and Catholicism) and the dichotomy between contemplation and action. The debate around the merits of each, how they are distinct, and also perhaps which one should “win.” I was struck by the relevance of our work in public administration. The purposeful and thoughtful work of planning, assessing, thinking, dwelling — on project possibilities, major decisions, goal-setting and so-forth. Some might call this mindful, others might call this passive. And the bias for action folks, who want to move, get things done, see progress, complete projects and effectuate the great work of public service. Finding that rhythm (and that staff complement to balance) in the contemplative vs the active is like finding gold.
Small Resets
Often times, we aim for that drastic change, that massive evolution, that monumental shake-up with some practice, project or habit. Here’s a quick-tip: just start small. Aim for a small reset. Reduce to writing one thing that’s a challenge, the myriad (if applicable) reasons why it is such, and then 1-2 things you can change up this week to improve the situation. Make a mental note or calendar entry to revisit this in one week’s time and re-evaluate and assess progress. Repeat.
Thanksgiving
The platitudes, many of which I express on the daily it would seem, perhaps get old for some people. “We have so much to be grateful for.” “Let’s always be thankful,” and so forth. However, the thing is - they are tried and everlasting adages because, well, they’re true! I do a gratitude journal entry every single day, and have for about ~10 years. I never run out of things to be grateful for. Today, with a real-feel of 18 degrees and blowing wind, it was a “warm home.” With my family together for the holiday, it was also “time with family.” With some sickness among people I know and love, it was also “my health and well-being.” The science on happiness backs this up. Make that one seminal element of Thanksgiving — expressing thanks for our blessings — a #365 day tradition.